Pond Saksit Shutterstock
1438400567
hand of bbq grilling and friends having barbecue party, outdoors
A great tailgate is not about putting the most food on the table. It is about building the right lineup and doing enough before kickoff that the host gets to enjoy the party, too.
That does not mean abandoning wings, dips, or anything served on a slider bun. It means giving the menu a little more thought, and making sure the food works for the way people actually eat while watching a game.
Private chef and Southlake Style Readers’ Choice winner Aly Romero knows how to make familiar food feel party-worthy. Her first rule for a great game-day spread: keep it handheld.
“Wings, sliders, skewers, or dips,” Romero says. “Something that’s going to be a couple bites and easy to eat, easy to prepare, but elevated beyond your typical burgers or hot dogs.”
Pick A Theme
The best game-day spreads are not necessarily the biggest. They are edited. Rather than filling the table with a dozen unrelated dishes, Romero likes to begin with a theme and choose one item to serve as the star of the menu.
The teams, hometowns, or host city can all provide inspiration. For championship games, dishes representing your favorite team can turn the menu into part of the competition. Romero recently built a World Cup soccer watch party around Spanish tapas, serving patatas bravas, garlic shrimp with tomato toast, smoked paprika chicken skewers, and a fresh arugula, fennel, and citrus salad.
A theme also makes the inevitable “What can I bring?” question much easier to answer. Guests can contribute something that fits the plan rather than arriving with the fourth bowl of queso.
Choose One Star Player
From there, Romero recommends building a balanced lineup: one star dish, something fresh, something warm, something that can sit comfortably at room temperature, and something sweet.
The main event might be reverse-seared tri-tip sliders with chimichurri, pulled pork sandwiches, or grilled steak skewers. None requires a knife and fork, and none leaves guests trying to manage an oversized sandwich while standing in a parking lot.
A build-your-own nacho bar offers the same flexibility with even less assembly for the host. Keep queso warm in a slow cooker and set out chips, grilled chicken or steak, pulled pork, candied jalapeños, onions, cilantro, salsa, guacamole, and shredded cheese. It gives guests choices without forcing the cook to make multiple entrées.
Even the usual tailgate suspects can benefit from a little zhuzh. Buffalo chicken dip is more interesting than a standard layered dip. Queso can get an upgrade from poblanos and pepper jack. Wings might take on Middle Eastern spices with a Greek yogurt dip or an Asian-inspired lemongrass sauce. Skewers can go in nearly any direction, from teriyaki to fajita-style steak with chimichurri.
The goal is not to make tailgating fussy, but to make familiar food feel more exciting.
Prep Is Your Pregame
The work, however, should happen before the party begins.
“I’m always a do-things-ahead person,” Romero says. “Being organized is the key, so you can relax later.”
Marinate the wings, thread the skewers, mix the sauces, and assemble the sliders at home. Dips can be prepared in advance and reheated over a flame or in a slow cooker. Meats can be cooked most of the way before guests arrive, leaving only a quick finish on the grill.
That philosophy matters even more for an early game. Romero’s first choice is a batch of foil-wrapped breakfast tacos filled with eggs, bacon, sausage or chorizo, crispy potatoes, and salsa. Breakfast sandwiches on English muffins travel just as easily.
What should not be on the menu? Anything that keeps the host working while everyone else is having fun.
“Nobody wants to be flipping pancakes in the middle of a parking lot,” Romero says.
The bottom line: the winning spread is the one that feeds a crowd easily and lets the host make it to kickoff, too.